Are Madewell Jeans Worth It? Reviewing Madewell Bestsellers

You’ve seen them on some of your favorite influencers, but are Madewell Jeans worth it? We’re trying out some Madewell bestsellers so you don’t have to. This post contains affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Here is the full site disclaimer. Original Post Date October 23, 2022.

best Madewell jeans for women

If you’re like me shopping for denim can be a delicate subject. Especially if your body has changed since having kids.

I’ve tried several denim brands but haven’t found a brand that consistently hits it out of the ballpark.

I started seeing a lot of influencers mention Madewell, so I decided to give them a try. I wanted to try them in-store and was happy to learn that there were a few Madewell locations in my area.

Upon entering the store I noticed the styling lends more to a casual, laid-back style which I love for the fall and winter seasons.

I also appreciate that the brand’s primary focus is on one item – jeans!


Madewell claims they are denim perfections for their standard to use the best fabrics and newest technologies to make every pair.

I also appreciate sustainably conscious brands. According to Madewell, by 2025, 90% of their denim will be Fair Trade Certified.

Another way Madewell is doing good for the community is by providing a sort of “buy back” program for your pre-loved denim.

They’ll send you a pre-paid shipping label for you to send in your used jeans. They are then resold or recycled and you get a Madewell credit.



I did a little research before my Madewell visit and noticed that The Perfect Vintage Jean was the brand’s signature denim style.

So it was the first pair I looked for in-store. I’ll be honest, it can be a little intimidating when you visit the store because there are a ton of styles to choose from.

The trick is to take inventory of your closet and shop for the pair that you are either missing or looking to try. I have so many skinny jeans so it was not a priority for me to look for skinny jeans.

The Perfect Vintage Jean is a waist-accentuating high rise with a slightly tapered leg. These remind me of my Levi’s icon jeans. Very flattering if you are on the curvier side.

I went with the medium indigo Heathcote wash. Unfortunately, the style and wash combo is sold out but I found this wash very universal.

I did find it in The Perfect Vintage Wide-Leg Jean if you want to check it out. There is also a petite version of this denim. It fits like true jeans as in it doesn’t have much stretch.

The salesperson did mention that they tend to stretch out the more you wear them. I usually get a size 28 but she recommended a size 27.

I did get the size 27 because I have noticed with my Levi’s that they will stretch a bit with each wear. The Perfect Vintage is made of 99% cotton and 1% elastane low-stretch Orta denim.

These are 11 1/4″ high rise jeans that hit above your belly button.

While they are full-length jeans (28″ inseam), they hit right above my ankle bone. Perfect for showing off cute loafers or booties this fall. This is also a great capsule wardrobe find to add to your collection.


While I wasn’t in the market for skinny jeans, this pair grew on me. Although the style is categorized as straight leg, it fits more like skinny jeans on me. Madewell describes the Stovepipe jeans as high rise with a narrow, slim-straight leg.

These Stovepipe jeans are in the banberry wash; a muted, faded black fabric with a raw hem.

It’s made of 92% cotton, 6% poly, and 2% elastane ISKO™ denim. These were more ankle-styled jeans and hit about 3cm above my ankle bone with a raw hem.

It also has a 10 1/2″ mid-rise which is usually right below your belly button.

If you are under 5’4″ they recommend the petite sizing. And if you are over 5’9″ you should opt for the tall sizing.

This pair will look great with Chelsea boots or other ankle booties. It also had a bit of a stretch, but I ordered my true size of 28 hoping it would wear a little looser.

The fabric is soft and easy to move in. If you can’t quit skinny jeans, this would be a great updated alternative.

However, I will be returning this pair because it’s my least favorite of the three. I was not completely sold on fit throughout the leg. I did like the wash so I’m thinking of getting this faded black color in The Perfect Vintage style.

The Stovepipe is available in blue, black, and whitewashes as well as a maternity option with an elasticized side panel.


Finally, the best-selling Kick Out Crop jeans are easily one of my favorites of the bunch. I love the slight flare.

It’s not too exaggerated and almost worn like straight jeans. I purchased them in the Glenside wash; a medium wash with slight whiskering in the front.

It had minimal stretch so I got my TTS 28. These jeans are also available in plus, petite, and tall sizes. They have a 10 1/2″ mid-rise with a 27″ cropped inseam.

This denim style is made of 99% cotton and 1% spandex high-stretch denim.

I love these jeans! They are my most-worn pair of denim because they are so flattering and comfortable.

I prefer denim that is a little cropped to show off footwear and this pair did exactly that.


Despite the over $100 price tag, yes, Madewell jeans are worth it. While my jeans price threshold used to hover around $80, I am willing to pay more for a pair of denim that has a really good fit and material.

Madewell jeans also hold up in the wash and maintains its shape after many wears. Madewell also has multiple sales throughout the years with discounts up to 50% if you sign up to become a Madewell Insider, their loyalty program which is free to join.


This post was all about a Madewell jeans review.

Join us on a stylish journey where we share our favorite finds and insider tips, transforming everyday moments into unforgettable expressions of personal style and confidence

notion templates for productivity
Amazon Storefront
things to do in houston

What's On Your Mind?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.